Does Julia Gillard Have Balls?

The day after her election as the first Australian Prime Minister, all the talk is about the nature of gender and its relationship to power.  On the one hand, people on the left are celebrating the rise to power of a women who is strong, independent, unmarried and has no children (and is apparently an athiest).  On the other hand, people on the right are lamenting the thought that a women has to become like a man to get the top job.

This latter assumption, however, is based on a false premise.  The principal of Alphacrucis College, Steven Fogarty (his colloquium presentation on this topic at this link), has recently been doing doctoral research in the relationship between gender and leadership.  It has sometimes been assumed that men are more likely to take hierarchical and power based approaches to leadership, and women relational and participative approaches – in formal terms, that men are more likely to lead transactionally, and women transformationally. Yet Fogarty’s research, along with other sociological studies, has rejected these gender based assertions.  In fact, what he has concluded is that the style of leadership is determined not by gender but, rather, by the requirements of the role.

Fogarty’s point can be illustrated by Gillard’s ascendancy.  To become Prime Minister, a person needs to be able to exercises power, to manipulate political situations, and to do so decisively and sometimes brutally (just ask Kim Beasley about Kevin Rudd’s skills in this regard).  No doubt there are other characteristics necessary for the job, but these are the ones that are traditionally described as “masculine” and that will be used to disparage the femininity of our new Prime Minister.  Fogarty’s research, however, reminds us that Gillard’s skills as a leader (and as someone capable of stabbing a colleague in the back) are no indication of gender but, sadly, are just the prerequisites needed for anyone who wants to get the top job in politics.

Aside from the research, i should also say that, as a man, i take offense to the suggestion that such capacities are necessarily or exclusively male – as do my female colleagues at the assertion that women cannot be feminine AND powerful, decisive (and unmarried and childless).  Just because all previous  decisive Prime Ministers have been men, it does not mean that strength, determination, ruthlessness etc. are male characteristics – that is a non sequiter (a leap in logic).

So does Julia Gillard have balls?  Only her partner can answer that question, but i think we can safely presume the answer is no.

2 thoughts on “Does Julia Gillard Have Balls?

  1. You have rightly pointed out there is a two way problem in regards to leadership / societal expectations and gender. It would appear that both the left and right have a sweeping stereo typical view of what masculine and feminine traits should be.

    While it would appear that there has to be certain unsavorable traits and actions for politicians to follow, I believe there have been many Godly politicians who haven’t resorted to such tactics to succeed….and indeed I would hope that the political scene will continue to be an area for Christians to actively bring about an redemptive presence.

    On another front, I have heard many celebrate her getting into office soley because she is a woman. I think it is dangerous to celebrate any filled position on a gender basis whether it be male or female. The true questions to ask before we can celebrate / commisserate Julias prime ministerial position have to be based on her ability to do the job for the betterment of Australia. I feel to celebrate her achievement on a gender basis only, denigrates her personal achievements, character and hard work to get to where she is….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s